← All Calculators
Deductible Optimizer
Higher deductible = lower premium, but is it actually saving you money?
Your Policy
5-Year Cost Comparison
$250
$165/mo · $200 deductibles
$10,090
5-yr total
$500
$150/mo · $400 deductibles
$9,400
5-yr total
$1,000
$136/mo · $800 deductibles
$8,959
5-yr total
$1,500
$124/mo · $1,200 deductibles
$8,618
5-yr total
$2,000
$113/mo · $1,600 deductibles
$8,375
5-yr total
$2,500BEST
$105/mo · $2,000 deductibles
$8,330
5-yr total
Our recommendation
$2,500 deductible
saves you the most over 5 years based on your claim frequency
Want to optimize beyond your deductible?
Compare quotes from 40+ carriers — many offer lower rates for the same deductible.
Get Your Free QuoteEstimates for educational purposes only. Actual rates vary by carrier and individual factors.